Tender Masculinity in Fifty Dead Men Walking

Fifty Dead Men Walking is based on the true story of Martin McGarland, who was recruited to spy on the IRA during the Troubles in Ireland.  Just as the film shows that the conflict was not black and white, it also shows a masculinity that is far from black and white.  Martin, played by Jim Sturgess, exhibits a lot of typical male-action-hero behaviours – he can be cocky, he’s shown as a mischevious trouble-maker from the start (pardon the pun!), and he does a lot of running and fighting in the film, showing a masculinity that is brave, determined and strong.  However, he has his sensitivity as well. We see his emotional pain at the deaths of those from “the other side.” We see his reluctance to kill.  We see his devotion to his girlfriend and family, and his respect for the strong women in his life.

Physically, he has a certain look about him that suggests sexy mystery combined with tenderness.  The way he positions his face slightly outward can be interpreted as a challenge to a fight from a violent male, but more so it seems to deliver a more “feminine” sense of vulnerability, as if he’s about to get hit. I remember reading an interview with the director of Fifty Dead Men Walking, Kari Skogland, and she said that it was that quality of vulnerability about Sturgess that drew her to him for the role. Sturgess has eye-candy status in Hollywood, and I wonder if this is in spite of or because of this vulnerability? Does pop culture value male tenderness?

This entry was posted in film. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Tender Masculinity in Fifty Dead Men Walking

  1. Cat says:

    I think it fits into the category of being “because of” the vulnerability. It might be a bit pessimistic of me, but I would say that Hollywood only cares about male tenderness as far as it will help them sell movies. By providing aggression and vulnerability, they hit more target demographics, and therefore make more money.

  2. Jasmeet says:

    I definitely think presenting male tenderness is a way to reach a wide range of audiences. I’m pretty sure most women won’t mind seeing a tough man who can also exhibit his vulnerable side– it’s nice seeing a guy who isn’t afraid to show his emotions, at least I think so.

  3. tiamercedes says:

    Again, back to using the Old Spice guy as an example! He is considered the epitome of what a man should be like (in the eyes of a woman’s perspective) because he balances his toughness and dominance with his tenderness. Because of that, they are able to sell male body products not only to their male audiences, but to the women as well for the men in their life.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s